Archive Text
Introduction: A Fatal Proposition in the Valley of Light
In the remote, unforgiving mountains of northeastern Afghanistan lies Nuristan Province, a region historically known as the "Land of Light." For the American soldiers of Bravo Troop, 3rd Squadron, 61st Cavalry Regiment, it was anything but. Their home in 2009 was Combat Outpost (COP) Keating, a small, isolated base nestled deep in a valley, surrounded on all four sides by towering, jagged peaks. The strategic placement was a catastrophic flaw, a reality not lost on the men who lived there. They were at the bottom of a geographic fishbowl, a pre-made kill zone where the enemy could look down upon their every move.
COP Keating and its nearby observation post, OP Fritsche, were established as part of a counter-insurgency (COIN) strategy aimed at building relationships with the local populace and stemming the flow of insurgents from nearby Pakistan. The goal was to connect with village elders, support the Afghan government, and provide security. In reality, the outpost's location made it almost impossible to defend and alienated the very people it was meant to engage. The local population was a complex mix of tribes, many of whom were deeply suspicious of, if not openly hostile to, any foreign or Afghan government presence.
The soldiers of B Troop, 3-61 Cavalry, part of the 4th Infantry Division's 4th Brigade Combat Team, understood their predicament with grim clarity. The outpost was a magnet for attack. They were subjected to frequent, though often inaccurate, rocket and mortar fire. The insurgents used the high ground for observation, mapping out the camp's defenses, routines, and weak points day by day. The Americans knew a major, coordinated attack was not a matter of if, but when. Intelligence reports grew increasingly ominous, filled with chatter about a massive enemy force gathering in the surrounding villages, preparing for a final, decisive assault to overrun the outpost.
Tragically, command had already recognized the untenable nature of COP Keating. A plan was in motion for its closure and withdrawal. The soldiers were literally counting down the days until they would abandon the valley for good. But the enemy, it seemed, had its own timeline. As October 2009 began, the air in the Kamdesh valley was thick with a palpable tension, the quiet before a storm of unimaginable fury. The men of what would become known as Red Platoon, and their comrades in B Troop, were about to face the ultimate test of survival in one of the most intense and brutal battles of the entire war in Afghanistan.
The Gathering Storm: Prelude to October 3rd
The weeks leading up to the main attack were characterized by a steady escalation of enemy activity. Probing attacks became more frequent and more accurate. Insurgents would fire a few rounds or a rocket-propelled grenade (RPG) at the outpost before melting back into the treacherous terrain, testing the American response times and observation capabilities. For the soldiers, it was a nerve-wracking existence. The sense of being constantly watched was suffocating. They knew the enemy was using the high ground, a tactical advantage so complete it bordered on the absurd, to learn everything about them. They could see where the command post was, where the barracks were, the location of the mortar pit, and the daily routines of the soldiers on guard duty.
The American force at COP Keating consisted of approximately 53 U.S. soldiers. They were augmented by a contingent of around 30 Afghan National Army (ANA) soldiers, whose reliability and combat effectiveness were often in question, and a pair of Latvian military trainers. Their primary defense rested on a handful of key positions: a 120mm mortar pit, several Humvees mounted with heavy machine guns, and fighting positions dug into the perimeter. OP Fritsche, situated on higher ground some distance away, provided overwatch but was itself isolated and difficult to reinforce.
The commander of B Troop, Captain Stoney Portis, and his leadership team were acutely aware of the danger. They repeatedly voiced their concerns about the outpost's vulnerability. The plan to close Keating was a welcome relief, but the process of withdrawal was slow and deliberate. Equipment and personnel were being moved out in stages, a process that further degraded the outpost's already limited defensive capabilities.
In the final days of September and the first days of October, the intelligence became chillingly specific. Local sources reported that hundreds of fighters—a coalition of local Taliban, Hezb-e-Islami Gulbuddin (HIG) militants, and foreign fighters from Pakistan and beyond—were massing for an attack. The number was estimated to be between 300 and 400, a force that would outnumber the American defenders by at least six to one. The objective was clear: to completely overrun COP Keating, kill or capture its defenders, and score a major propaganda victory against the U.S. forces.
On the night of October 2nd, the valley was unnaturally quiet. The usual harassing fire was absent. For some, it was a brief respite. For the more experienced soldiers, it was the final, terrifying confirmation that something big was about to happen. They checked their weapons, double-checked their ammunition, and tried to get what little rest they could. They were unknowingly on the precipice of a battle that would define their lives and earn its place in the annals of U.S. military history.
06:00 Hours, October 3, 2009: The Sky Falls
Just before dawn, the storm broke. The attack began not with a single shot, but with a deafening, simultaneous eruption of violence from every direction. The 360-degree high ground that surrounded COP Keating became a firing platform for a coordinated barrage of RPGs, heavy machine guns, recoilless rifles, and mortars. The initial volley was not random; it was a precise, targeted assault designed to decapitate the outpost's ability to fight back.
The first rockets slammed into the most critical targets. The command post was hit, shredding communications antennas and sowing chaos among the leadership. The mortar pit, the Americans' most powerful indirect fire weapon, was showered with RPGs and machine-gun fire, killing and wounding the crew and rendering the big gun useless within the first minutes of the fight. The generator that powered the outpost was destroyed, plunging sections of the base into darkness and silencing vital electronic systems.
The sound was a physical force—a continuous, roaring cataclysm of explosions and the supersonic crack of bullets. For the soldiers jolted from their sleep, the world had become a whirlwind of fire, smoke, and shrapnel. They scrambled for their body armor and weapons in the chaos, the barracks buildings around them being systematically torn apart by enemy fire.
The insurgents' plan was brutally effective. They achieved fire superiority almost instantly, pinning down the American defenders in their isolated positions. The sheer volume of incoming fire was overwhelming. It kicked up dust and debris, creating a thick, choking fog of war that obscured vision and made movement a suicidal proposition. The ANA positions on the perimeter crumbled almost immediately. Faced with the terrifying onslaught, many of the Afghan soldiers broke and fled, abandoning their posts and leaving critical gaps in the defensive line. Some fought bravely, but as a cohesive force, they dissolved.
Within the first 30 minutes, the situation was dire. The command structure was struggling to communicate, the most powerful weapon was silenced, and the perimeter was beginning to fail. Insurgents, emboldened by their initial success, began to advance down the hillsides, moving closer to the wire, preparing for the final phase of their attack: to breach the compound and finish the defenders in close-quarters combat. For the men of B Troop, trapped at the bottom of the valley, the battle for survival had just begun.
The Fight for the Perimeter: A Circle of Hell
With the outpost's defenses reeling, the battle devolved into a series of desperate, isolated fights for survival. Small groups of soldiers, cut off from one another, held their ground against overwhelming odds. The perimeter, which was flimsy to begin with, became the critical line between life and death.
A key focal point of the fighting was the Entry Control Point (ECP) at the main gate. This area, along with the adjacent Afghan police station, was a major weakness. The insurgents concentrated their forces here, and after the ANA lines collapsed, they breached the wire. Enemy fighters poured into the compound, getting inside the American perimeter and threatening to slice the outpost in half.
Staff Sergeant Clinton Romesha, a section leader in the troop, quickly emerged as a central figure in the defense. Realizing that the loss of the ECP would mean the certain death of everyone in the outpost, he began to organize a counterattack. The initial attempts were beaten back by a hail of fire. The enemy had established a foothold and was using the captured buildings for cover.
Meanwhile, other soldiers were trapped in their positions. A handful of men were pinned down inside a Humvee, using its armor for protection while returning fire with its heavy machine gun. Their position was precarious; a well-aimed RPG could turn their shelter into a fiery tomb. Snipers and machine gunners on the high ground had a clear line of sight to nearly every part of the outpost, making any movement in the open a deadly gamble.
One of the most isolated and perilous positions was held by Specialist Ty Carter. He was pinned down in a different sector of the base, separated from the main defensive effort. From his position, he laid down suppressive fire, trying to keep the enemy from advancing further. The air was thick with bullets, and he witnessed several of his comrades get hit.
The ammo supply point, a small building near the ECP, was set ablaze by an RPG. It quickly became a raging inferno, with ammunition cooking off in a series of terrifying explosions. This not only added to the chaos but also threatened to destroy the very resource the defenders needed most. The loss of the main ammo dump was a devastating blow, forcing soldiers to conserve what they had on their person or risk their lives to scavenge from the wounded and the dead.
The command post, though damaged, was still functioning. Captain Portis and his team worked frantically to coordinate the defense and, most importantly, to call for air support. They knew that without help from the sky, they would be annihilated. The radios crackled with desperate pleas for close air support (CAS), but the response was hampered by the extreme terrain and the initial shock of the coordinated attack, which was taking place across the region.
The battle had become a visceral, close-range affair. The enemy was inside the wire. American soldiers were fighting hand-to-hand in some cases, using rifles, grenades, and sheer grit to hold back the tide. Every corner of COP Keating had become a battlefield.
The Counterattack: Taking Back Keating
As the morning wore on, the outpost was on the brink of collapse. The perimeter was breached in multiple locations, the main ammo supply was gone, and casualties were mounting. It was in this moment of extreme crisis that the training, discipline, and raw courage of the American NCOs and soldiers turned the tide.
Staff Sergeant Romesha, recognizing that a passive defense would lead to annihilation, made a bold decision. He would lead a small team to retake the ECP and the burning ammo building, push the enemy out of the wire, and secure a new perimeter around the core of the outpost. It was a seemingly suicidal mission, a charge directly into the heart of the enemy's strength.
Gathering a handful of volunteers, Romesha laid out a simple, audacious plan. They would use a captured Russian-made machine gun for suppressive fire and move from cover to cover, overwhelming the insurgents who had taken up positions inside the compound. The charge was an act of incredible bravery. The men sprinted across open ground raked by machine-gun fire, their movements a blur of controlled aggression.
They reached the building next to the ECP and began the grim work of clearing it. Using grenades and rifle fire, they systematically fought their way through, driving the surprised insurgents back. The ferocity of the American counterattack seemed to stun the enemy, who had likely believed the outpost's defenders were broken. Romesha and his team pushed forward, their actions creating a ripple effect of confidence among the other defenders. They secured the area around the burning ammo dump and established a defensible line, effectively cutting off the main insurgent infiltration point. This single act of leadership and courage was the pivotal moment in the ground fight. It stabilized the collapsing defense and gave the Americans a foothold from which to fight back.
While Romesha led the charge, Specialist Carter was engaged in his own heroic struggle. He had been providing suppressive fire from an exposed position when he saw that a fellow soldier, Specialist Stephan Mace, had been gravely wounded and was lying in the open, in a direct line of fire from an enemy machine gun. With complete disregard for his own safety, Carter decided he had to get to him.
He made multiple attempts to reach Mace, each time being driven back by a torrent of bullets. Finally, under the covering fire of Sergeant Bradley Larson, Carter sprinted across what his comrades would later call the "kill zone"—a hundred yards of open ground completely exposed to enemy fire. He reached the wounded soldier, administered first aid, and, with the help of Larson, carried him back to the relative safety of the aid station, all while under continuous, accurate enemy fire. Carter’s actions saved Mace from bleeding to death on the battlefield and exemplified the warrior ethos of never leaving a fallen comrade.
These two acts, one of tactical leadership and one of individual valor, were emblematic of the fighting spirit shown across the outpost. Other soldiers continued to hold their positions, suppress the enemy on the hillsides, and care for the wounded, all while fighting for their own lives.
The Cavalry from the Sky: Air Power Arrives
For hours, the defenders of COP Keating had fought alone. Their desperate calls for air support were finally answered as the weather cleared enough for aircraft to enter the valley. The arrival of the first AH-64 Apache attack helicopters was a turning point. The sound of their rotors was a morale boost for the beleaguered Americans and a death knell for the insurgents.
The Apache pilots were masters of their craft, navigating the treacherous mountain valley to deliver devastatingly accurate fire. Their 30mm cannons tore into the insurgent positions on the high ground, forcing the enemy fighters to abandon their well-chosen spots and seek cover. The tide of fire, which had been flowing one way for hours, was now being turned back on the attackers.
Soon, other assets joined the fight. A-10 Thunderbolt II "Warthog" aircraft, famous for their durability and the distinctive, terrifying sound of their GAU-8 Avenger Gatling guns, flew sorties over the valley. They raked the hillsides, unleashing a hellish rain of cannon fire and bombs on the massed enemy forces. B-1 Lancer bombers, high above, were called in to drop precision munitions on larger concentrations of fighters who had been flushed out into the open by the helicopters and A-10s.
The air support was decisive. It broke the back of the coordinated attack, killing scores of insurgents and disrupting their command and control. The fighters who had so confidently swarmed down the hillsides were now trapped in the open, hunted from the sky. The overwhelming fire superiority they had enjoyed for the first few hours of the battle was gone, replaced by a terrifying vulnerability.
With the pressure from the hillsides relieved, the soldiers on the ground could focus on clearing the last remaining insurgents from within the outpost's perimeter. The combination of the heroic ground counterattack and the timely arrival of overwhelming air power had saved COP Keating from being overrun. By late afternoon, the Quick Reaction Force (QRF) finally arrived, flying in to help secure the outpost and evacuate the wounded. The main battle was over.
The Aftermath: Counting the Cost
As dusk fell on October 3rd, the guns fell silent, replaced by the grim and sorrowful task of accounting for the aftermath. The cost of defending COP Keating had been staggering. Eight American soldiers had been killed in action, and 27 more were wounded, representing a casualty rate of over 60 percent of the U.S. force. The dead were:
Sgt. Justin T. Gallegos
Sgt. Christopher T. Griffin
Sgt. Joshua M. Hardt
Sgt. Joshua J. Kirk
Spc. Stephan L. Mace (who later died of his wounds)
Staff Sgt. Vernon W. Martin
Pfc. Kevin C. Thomson
Pfc. Michael P. Scusa
The outpost itself was a wreck. Buildings were smoldering ruins, the ground was littered with brass casings and the debris of battle, and the perimeter was shattered. The victory, if it could be called that, was paid for in blood.
The enemy had also paid a heavy price. It is estimated that approximately 150 insurgent fighters were killed, largely due to the devastating air strikes that caught them in the open.
In the days that followed, the decision was made to do what should have been done months earlier. COP Keating was to be fully evacuated and permanently closed. The surviving soldiers gathered their wounded, their dead, and what little equipment was salvageable and were airlifted out of the valley. A few days later, on October 6th, an American B-1 bomber returned to the empty outpost one last time. It dropped a series of massive bombs, obliterating what remained of COP Keating and ensuring it could never be used as a propaganda trophy by the enemy. The final destruction of the base was a grim, explosive admission of its strategic failure.
Legacy and Recognition: Lessons Forged in Fire
The Battle of Kamdesh became one of the most studied engagements of the war in Afghanistan. It served as a brutal and costly lesson on the dangers of establishing small, indefensible outposts deep in enemy territory without the ability to adequately support or reinforce them. The strategy of placing soldiers in such vulnerable "COIN outposts" was heavily re-evaluated, and many such bases across eastern Afghanistan were subsequently closed.
The immense courage displayed by the defenders of COP Keating did not go unrecognized. The battle produced two living recipients of the Medal of Honor, the nation's highest award for valor—the first time this had occurred for the same battle since the Vietnam War.
Staff Sergeant Clinton Romesha was awarded the Medal of Honor for his incredible leadership in organizing and leading the counterattack that retook the outpost. His citation noted his actions were critical in preventing the base from being overrun.
Specialist Ty Carter was also awarded the Medal of Honor for his repeated acts of heroism, most notably for risking his life to cross a field of fire to rescue a wounded comrade and for his tenacity in continuing the fight despite being isolated and under intense pressure.
Beyond these two, the battle was a testament to the bravery of every soldier in B Troop. Dozens of other medals, including the Distinguished Service Cross, Silver Stars, and Bronze Stars with "V" for valor, were awarded to the men who fought at COP Keating. The battle became a modern epic of American soldiery: a story of survival, sacrifice, and brotherhood in the face of impossible odds.
The legacy of COP Keating is twofold. It is a stark reminder of a strategic blunder, a failure of command to protect its soldiers from an obvious and foreseeable danger. But more importantly, it is an enduring monument to the valor of the American soldier. When faced with a catastrophic situation, the men of B Troop, 3-61 Cavalry did not break. They fought with a ferocity and courage that turned a certain defeat into a costly but undeniable victory, holding the line against a vastly superior force and saving one another in the crucible of combat. Their story, as told in books like "Red Platoon" and official histories, will forever stand as a profound example of what soldiers can endure, and achieve, when everything is on the line.
Files
There are no files available.